Reading Sheet Music vs. Playing by Ear: Which is Superior?

by | Aug 8, 2016 | Beginners

reading sheet music vs playing by ear

Are you scratching your head wondering which is better; reading sheet music or playing by ear? In this blog post, we review each of the techniques.

What’s the Difference?

Reading sheet music involves looking at written music, then translating the notation into the physical movements needed to play the song. The written music instructs you what and how to play.

On the other hand, playing by the ear is listening to a song to help you know how to play it.  With practice what you hear can guide you as to what to play.

Reading Sheet Music

Reading sheet music is the traditional way of learning music. You read everything that you play.  It is a straightforward way of learning music. It is what most music teachers teach.

Advantages of reading and playing from sheet music include:

  • It is comparatively easy since you get detailed guidance throughout the whole reading sheet music vs playing by earpiece, therefore, no need to remember or improvise. Of course, it’s only easy once you know how to read music or tab notation.
  • There is a lot of learning material for guidance. Many books on learning music will give you ample material on this technique.
  • In a group performance such as an orchestra or a band, having to read from a sheet music ensures everybody is in sync. It guides the whole performance.
  • It provides the essential foundational skills and principles of music. Therefore, it prevents pick up of habits and practices that might derail your progress.

Playing by Ear

While many wish they could read music, all of us admire a person who can pick up an instrument and just play a tune on it without any notes.

reading sheet music vs playing by earThis technique, admittedly, can be harder to master.Your mind will have to learn to do the reverse of reading and playing sheet music. However, some people find playing by ear much easier than reading notes – and some people find reading notes much easier than playing by ear!

You listen to music playing and translate it into a mental sheet music. Finally, you then play it yourself.  With practice your brain can to directly from hearing a song to knowing how to play it.

The pros of learning by ear are:

  • You’ll learn new pieces faster this way because no time is used in processing the written sheet music first.
  • You develop the ability to improvise a song and add your signature style.
  • It improves your ability to create your own compositions.
  • It is a fun and exciting way to learn in addition to being handy where no sheet music is available.

Our Verdict

In conclusion, none of these techniques is superior to the other.  Both of them are efficient and useful.

Some teachers tend to focus more on reading sheet music and not so much on playing by ear. Doing this limits the students’ abilities. What if they don’t have the sheet music? What if they need to improvise the piece they are playing? What if they forget the piece? Then, they always have to start at the beginning and can’t work on the hard parts.

We, therefore, think it necessary to learn both techniques. As earlier mentioned, playing by ear is not exactly an easy thing to do. Most people start by learning sheet music first. Through disciplined practice,  they eventually learn to play music by ear too.

Happy Strumming!

If you want to play the latest hits, you need to learn essential skills first. 21 MORE Songs in 6 Days will teach you these skills.

Get your copy now!

  1. Teach a Rest Position

Create a standard position players use whenever they are listening:

  • Place the ukulele flat against the body.
  • Rest the strumming hand gently on the strings.
  • Keep both hands still.
  • Look toward the leader.

Call it “rest position” and demonstrate it at the group’s first meeting. Use the same phrase consistently: “Ukuleles in rest position, please.”

This physically mutes the strings and gives everyone a clear visual signal that playing has stopped.

  1. Use One Attention Signal

Choose a signal that can be seen or heard across the room. Possibilities include:

  • Raising one hand
  • Playing a short, distinctive chord
  • Saying, “Rest position”

Explain the signal before rehearsal begins: “When you see my hand raised, finish the chord you are playing, mute your strings, and look up.”

Avoid competing with the group by repeatedly talking over the instruments. Give the signal, pause, and wait until everyone is ready.

  1. Set a Clear “No Noodling” Expectation

Many players noodle because they are excited, nervous, practicing a difficult chord, or unaware that it is distracting. Address the behavior without embarrassing anyone.

Try saying:

“Between songs, please mute your strings so everyone can hear the instructions. We’ll always give you a moment to check chords before we begin.”

Then build short, intentional practice windows into the session:

  • “Take 20 seconds to find the opening chord.”
  • “Quietly check the change from C to G7.”
  • “Let’s try that strum together once.”

Players are more likely to stop playing at random when they know when practice is welcome.

  1. Amplify the Leader, Not the Entire Room

In larger groups, a small microphone, portable speaker, or amplified ukulele can save the leader’s voice and make directions easier to follow. Amplification should provide clarity—not to overpower the players.

Test the equipment before the session, position the speaker where everyone can hear it, and keep spoken instructions short. A microphone cannot replace an attention routine, but it makes a good routine much more effective.

  1. Create Predictable Transitions

Noodling often fills uncertainty. Tell players exactly what is happening next:

    1. “Finish the final chord.”
    2. “Rest position.”
    3. “Turn to page 14.”
    4. “Find a C chord.”
    5. “Watch for my count-in.”

Use a visible or audible count-in before every song. Once players learn that nothing begins until the leader counts them in, spontaneous starts become less common.

6. Operate iPads for music.

Many ukulele groups read off iPads, and everyone buys the same app. forScore is one of the common ones, but don’t get anything until the group leader tells you which one they use. From there, the leader or the singer/songwriter shares the music by AirDrop, so everyone is reading off the same page. Corrections land with the whole group at once, and nobody is working from an outdated copy.

 

A Simple Group Agreement

At the beginning of a session, say:

“To help everyone hear and learn, we use rest position whenever someone is speaking. When I raise my hand, please mute your strings and look up. You’ll have time to check chords before each song, and we’ll always start together on the count-in.”

The goal is not silence for its own sake. It is to create a group in which instructions are brief, rehearsals move smoothly, and everyone gets more time to make music together.

 

Here’s a list of etiquette expectations from ukulele group members to make the group learning more effective and fruitful for everyone. 

Keep me posted about the release of 21 Easy Ukulele Hymns

Thanks for signing up - we'll keep you posted about the launch of 21 Easy Ukulele Hymns